Showing posts with label seen. Show all posts
Showing posts with label seen. Show all posts

Saturday, July 29, 2017

Debbie have you seen THE NIGHT TOURIST by Katherine Marsh

Debbie have you seen THE NIGHT TOURIST by Katherine Marsh


This "have you seen" post is, more or less, a note to myself to put Katherine Marshs The Night Tourist on my list of books to read. Of late, Im finding/learning about several books that are set in New York City and have Native content--in the form of ghosts or Indians-of-the-past.

The Night Tourist came to my attention as I read an article in the March 27 edition of The Washington Post. Written by Katherine Marsh (author of The Night Tourist), the photograph at the top of her article is what caught my eye. Heres a screen cap:



That soldier, with machine gun, standing in front of a book display is, of course, chilling. As my eyes moved to the books on the shelves, I realized the soldier is standing in front of a wall of Tintin books. The one on the top shelf, 3rd from the left, is Tintin in America. It is one of the much loved Tintin books have stereotypical, racist, derogatory content.

As I started looking into Tintin articles to link to in this post, I found an article in Salon: Tintins racist history: Symbol of Brussels solidarity is uncomfortably divisive. In it is a link to an article in Vox: How Tintin became the symbol of solidarity in the Brussels attacks. The Vox article is mostly a series of tweets of Tintin crying.

I dont know if Marsh chose the photo that was used with her article. She doesnt mention the Tintin books. My guess is that someone in the editorial department at the Post has read the Vox article and thought it a good choice, given that Marsh writes childrens books. The image did something else for me: it caught my eye and led me to look at Marshs first book, which (as noted above) has Native content of the no-longer-around kind, but it also captures the importance of childrens books.

Far too many people look down on children and the books created for them, but theyre important. They shape the ways we view the world. How they do that is something that needs more attention. When I read Marshs book, what will I find? Does that book add to the misinformation that Native peoples no longer exist? If/when I read her book, Ill be back. If youve read it, let me know what you noticed when you read it.
Read more »

Monday, July 24, 2017

Debbie have you seen Tara Lazars NORMAL NORMAN

Debbie have you seen Tara Lazars NORMAL NORMAN


A reader wrote to me about Tara Lazar and S. britts picture book, Normal Norman. Published in March of 2016 by Sterling Childrens Books, heres the synopsis:
What is "normal?" Thats the question an eager young scientist, narrating her very first book, hopes to answer. Unfortunately, her exceedingly"normal" subject�an orangutan named Norman�turns out to be exceptionally strange. He speaks English, sleeps in a bed, loves his stuffed toy, goes bananas over pizza, and even deep-sea dives! Oh, no: whats a "normal" scientist to do? A humorous look at the wackiness that makes us all special� and a gentle reminder that "normal" cant ever be defined!
The reader noted a page in the book where a bear is playing with puppets... one of whom is an Indian. Heres that image:



Why is that puppet there? When I get to a bookstore or library, Ill see if I can figure it out.

Read more »

Saturday, July 22, 2017

Debbie have you seen THE DRAGON HAMMER by Tony Daniel

Debbie have you seen THE DRAGON HAMMER by Tony Daniel


A reader wrote to ask if Ive seen Tony Daniels The Dragon Hammer. Heres excerpts from the review from Publishers Weekly. In the excerpt Ive highlighted a passage...
Beast-men, bitter feuds, and battles are just some of the elements in this epic coming-of-age fantasy, set in an alternate North America populated by Viking-like settlements, Romans who practice blood magic, and mythical creatures. 
and
First in the Wulf Saga, the story is a kitchen sink of fantasy tropes, with elves and gnomes existing alongside animal-human hybrids (who replace a native population in a regrettable worldbuilding decision), and a vaguely explained mythology involving stars and dragons.
Reviews indicate the story is set in the Shenandoah Valley. Shenandoah is a Native word. I assume the author needed some words in order to make this story identifiable as one in "an alternative North America." 

I wonder if Daniel or his editor saw the Publishers Weekly review? Im glad their reviewer questioned that worldbuilding! Im questioning it, too!

The Dragon Hammer was released on July 5, 2016, by Baen, which is part of Simon and Schuster. Heres the synopsis:
Evil from the dawn of time is on the verge of domination�but Wulf von Dunstig figured none of that mattered to him. What could he do about it? After all, he was basically nobody�the sixteen-year-old third son of a duke destined for an uneventful life as a ranger. But when destiny comes calling, it turns out there is only Wulf to answer. After a devastating invasion of his native land, Wulf must rally the peaceful valley of Shenandoah. He must free his family and his land from the grip of intruders controlled by vampiric evil.
Wulfs "native land" is being invaded? I agree with Publishers Weekly. This story sounds regrettable. 

Update, 5:35 AM, August 5th, 2016: As usual with the "Debbie--have you seen" posts, Ill be back with a review when I get a copy of the book. 

Read more »

Wednesday, July 19, 2017

Debbie have you seen Cammie McGoverns JUST MY LUCK

Debbie have you seen Cammie McGoverns JUST MY LUCK


A librarian in Nebraska wrote to ask me if Ive seen Cammie McGoverns Just My Luck. Released on February 23, 2016 from HarperCollins, heres the synopsis:
Critically acclaimed author Cammie McGoverns middle grade debut is a powerful and heartwarming story that will appeal to readers who loved R. J. Palacios Wonder, Ann M. Martins Rain Reign, and Holly Sloans Counting by 7s.
Fourth grade is not going at all how Benny Barrows hoped. He hasnt found a new best friend. Hes still not a great bike rider�even though his brother George, whos autistic, can do tricks. And worst of all, he worries his dads recent accident might be all his fault. Benny tries to take his moms advice and focus on helping others, and to take things one step at a time. But when his dad ends up in the hospital again, Benny doesnt know how he and his family will overcome all the bad luck that life seems to have thrown their way.
Just My Luck is a deeply moving and rewarding novel about a down-on-his-luck boy whose caring heart ultimately helps him find the strength to cope with tragedy and realize how much he truly has to offer his friends and family.

Just My Luck, the librarian wrote, references Indian in the Cupboard. Theres a copy in my local library. Ill pick it up, read it, and be back with a review.
Read more »

Saturday, July 15, 2017

Debbie have you seen Joan Crates BLACK APPLE

Debbie have you seen Joan Crates BLACK APPLE


A reader writes to ask if Ive seen Joan Crates Black Apple. Published in March of 2016 by Simon and Schuster, heres the synopsis:
A dramatic and lyrical coming-of-age novel about a young Blackfoot girl who grows up in the residential school system on the Canadian prairies.
Torn from her home and delivered to St. Mark�s Residential School for Girls by government decree, young Rose Marie finds herself in an alien universe where nothing of her previous life is tolerated, not even her Blackfoot name. For she has entered into the world of the Sisters of Brotherly Love, an order of nuns dedicated to saving the Indigenous children from damnation. Life under the sharp eye of Mother Grace, the Mother General, becomes an endless series of torments, from daily recitations and obligations to chronic sickness and inedible food. And then there are the beatings. All the feisty Rose Marie wants to do is escape from St. Mark�s. How her imagination soars as she dreams about her lost family on the Reserve, finding in her visions a healing spirit that touches her heart. But all too soon she starts to see other shapes in her dreams as well, shapes that warn her of unspoken dangers and mysteries that threaten to engulf her. And she has seen the rows of plain wooden crosses behind the school, reminding her that many students have never left here alive.
Set during the Second World War and the 1950s, Black Apple is an unforgettable, vividly rendered novel about two very different women whose worlds collide: an irrepressible young Blackfoot girl whose spirit cannot be destroyed, and an aging yet powerful nun who increasingly doubts the value of her life. It captures brilliantly the strange mix of cruelty and compassion in the residential schools, where young children are forbidden to speak their own languages and given Christian names. As Rose Marie matures, she finds increasingly that she knows only the life of the nuns, with its piety, hard work and self-denial. Why is it, then, that she is haunted by secret visions�of past crimes in the school that terrify her, of her dead mother, of the Indigenous life on the plains that has long vanished? Even the kind-hearted Sister Cilla is unable to calm her fears. And then, there is a miracle, or so Mother Grace says. Now Rose is thrust back into the outside world with only her wits to save her.
With a poet�s eye, Joan Crate creates brilliantly the many shadings of this heartbreaking novel, rendering perfectly the inner voices of Rose Marie and Mother Grace, and exploring the larger themes of belief and belonging, of faith and forgiveness.
Ill see if I can get a copy. If I do, Ill be back with a review.
Read more »

Friday, July 14, 2017

Debbie have you seen BELLA BELLA by Jonathan London

Debbie have you seen BELLA BELLA by Jonathan London


A reader writes to ask if Ive seen Bella Bella by Jonathan London, illustrations by Sean London (dont know if there is a relationship between the author and illustrator). Bella Bella came out in February of 2016. Published by West Winds, heres the synopsis:

From best-selling author Jonathan London comes BELLA BELLA, the heart-pounding sequel to DESOLATION CANYON. In this story for young readers, the same cast of characters?thirteen-year-olds Aaron and Lisa and their fathers, and seventeen-year-old Cassidy and his dad?embark on a sea kayaking trip through the Inside Passage that brings them unexpected and even terrifying adventures. Young readers will eagerly follow Aaron�s adventures in this suspenseful page turner, as he learns to navigate a kayak, discovers another side to a bully, shares a first kiss, encounters the desperate world of human trafficking, and challenges an evil smuggler who threatens the entire group.

Nothing in the synopsis to tell you theres Native content, but the art on the top half of the cover tells us there is (see image to the right). I dont know what to call that image. Is it meant to be a totem pole? What do you think it is?

The review at Kirkus tells us that the characters begin their trip at a First Nations village (Bella Bella) and that they hope to learn about First Nations tribes. The Kirkus review included a link to their review of Desolation Canyon, so I took a look at that review. It apparently has Native content, too.

If I get a copy, Ill be back with a review. If youve got a copy, please comment on what you see in it.




Read more »

Wednesday, July 12, 2017

Debbie have you seen THE CRYING ROCKS by Janet Taylor Lisle

Debbie have you seen THE CRYING ROCKS by Janet Taylor Lisle


A colleague wrote to ask if Ive seen anything about Janet Taylor Lisles The Crying Rocks. It is due out in May of 2017 from Simon and Schuster.

Heres the description:

From Newbery Honor author Janet Taylor Lisle comes a lyrical story about one girl�s discovery of her startling past�and her search to understand her complicated present.
Joelle�s height and dark skin set her apart from everyone in Marshfield. It�s no secret that she�s adopted, but where is she from? Aunt Mary Louise says she came from Chicago on a freight train, but the story doesn�t sit right with Joelle. There�s something more. She feels it.
Carlos, the quiet boy in Joelle�s Spanish class, sees it. When he tells her that she looks like a girl in the town library�s old mural of Narragansett Indians, Joelle can�t help sneaking a look. She�s surprised by a flicker of recognition. And when Carlos tells her about the Crying Rocks, where the ghosts of Narragansett children are said to cry for their lost mothers, Joelle knows she must visit them.
When they finally set out through the forest, neither she nor Carlos anticipates the power of the ancient place, or the revelations to be found there�about the pasts they�ve both buried, and the discovery of a rare kind of courage that runs deep in Joelle�s family.


As I started some of the background research about the book, I went to Lisles website and saw that it isnt a new book. It got awards and honors in 2004 and 2006. Heres an excerpt Lisle has on her website:
�What was that?� Carlos asks.
Joelle listens but hears nothing, only the sound of wind kicking branches overhead. "What?�
�A scream. Did you hear it?�
She shakes her head. "No. Nothing."
Carlos listens again. �Somewhere over there is a mass of glacial boulders called the Crying Rocks.� His face, in shadow, has taken on a stern, gaunt look. For the first time, Joelle sees, or imagines she sees, a vague outline of his Indian ancestry�something about his nose and the slope of his forehead. He is gazing intently into the forest.
�The story is that when you pass by these rocks at certain times, you hear children crying,� he says.
�Children! What children?�
Around them, tree shadows flick and twist.
�Ghosts of Indian children,� Carlos says. �They were killed there or something. A long time ago.�
�Its getting so dark,� Joelle murmurs.
In that moment an eerie feeling descends on them both.
�Lets get out of here,� Carlos whispers.
Why is it being republished? Did it get revised? Or is it being reissued with a new cover, with expectations that in this moment of diverse books, itll do well? It isnt an #OwnVoices story... and what I read of that excerpt... well, lets say Im not optimistic.

Heres an old cover and the new one:



If I hadnt done this background research, I might have bought the book when I dont need to... my library likely has a copy. If I read it, Ill be back.

Update (same day) -- a quick note: Some of the book is available online. I read that Carlos is "about one sixteenth or something" Sioux from "out West" (p. 15).
Read more »

Tuesday, July 11, 2017

Debbie have you seen A R Kahlers SHADES OF DARKNESS

Debbie have you seen A R Kahlers SHADES OF DARKNESS


Paula wrote to ask me about A.R. Kahlers Shades of Darkness. Published by Simon & Schuster, it is a 2016 young adult book whose main character, Kaira Winters, is "some unknown blend of Native American bloodlines" (p. 10).

Heres the synopsis:

American Gods meets The Secret History in this suspenseful start to a brand-new fantasy trilogy about a girl named Kaira Winters, the murders that keep happening at her artsy boarding school, and the lengths she must go to in order to protect the people she loves.
When Kaira Winters decided to go to Islington�a boarding school deep in the woods of Michigan�she thought she could finally get away from everything she has tried so hard to forget, including some things from her past that she refuses to believe ever actually happened.
Everything seemed great until the bodies of murdered students started appearing all over campus. The victims seem to have been killed in some sort of ritual sacrifice. And even worse, Kaira�s dreams are giving her clues to the killer�s identity.
Though she tries to resist, Kaira quickly realizes that she is the only one who can stop the violence, but to do so she must come to terms with her past. She�s going to have to listen to the voice that is buried deep within her�the one that claims to have unimaginable power�the one that claims to be an actual goddess.
But even if Kaira can harness the power within her, will it be enough to stop the darkness that has fallen over her school? And if it is strong enough, then what�s to stop the goddess from wreaking her own havoc once she�s released?


Course, I have lots of questions. This power within Kaira... is it because of her "unknown blend of Native American bloodlines" -- or not? "Goddess" gives me pause. Why did the author find it necessary to make Kairas identity of an "unknown blend of Native American bloodlines"? It seems decorative rather than substantive.

Another passage that caught my eye as I read the preview is the one about a Korean character, Jane (p. 9):
Her family was Korean, though shed lived in the States for so much of her childhood, her accent was flawless.
Lot to look at in that sentence, like that last word: flawless. Does Kaira think a person whose speech retains aspects of a mother tongue is flawed?

If I get a copy of Shades of Darkness, Ill be back with a review.

 
Read more »

Saturday, July 1, 2017

Debbie have you seen Kelly DiPucchios ONE LITTLE TWO LITTLE THREE LITTLE CHILDREN

Debbie have you seen Kelly DiPucchios ONE LITTLE TWO LITTLE THREE LITTLE CHILDREN


Some time back, someone (on Twitter, I think) asked me what I think of writers using the "one little, two little, three little Indians" in a new way. I dont recall the conversation itself; I only recall that I was asked about adaptions of that rhyme.

Today, Ive got an email from someone asking me if Ive seen Kelly DiPucchios picture book due out on May 3rd 2016 from Balzar + Bray. Now, that first question makes sense! DiPucchio has done that adaptation, and my guess is that the question was from someone who saw the book.

Heres the title of DiPucchios book, as presented on the cover:

one little
two little
three little
children

My guess is the number words are in italics to set them off, so that they can be read aloud apart from the other words. DiPucchios book is illustrated by Mary Lundquist. Heres the synopsis:
From bestselling author Kelly DiPucchio, with illustrations by Mary Lundquist, comes a charming new picture book in the vein of Liz Garton Scanlon�s All the World and Susan Meyers�s Everywhere Babies.
One Little Two Little Three Little Children�an exuberant reinvention of the classic children�s rhymeis pure read-aloud, sing-along joy and an irresistible celebration of all kinds of children and families.
The kids on the cover are of varying skin tones, in modern clothing. Hmmm.... A "reinvention"? Does it succeed?

The Kirkus review says:
Facing this page is a trio of homes: �Snow-cozy, / stick-cozy, / brick-cozy houses,� and herein lies the rub: the igloo and teepee depicted here are juxtaposed with a child making a structure of building blocks, undermining efforts at multicultural inclusion by falsely equating these so-called �snow� and �stick� structures with toys. These depictions also bring to the forefront the text�s similarities to versions of the rhyme referring to �One little, / two little, / three little Indians� that have been roundly critiqued as racist, or, even more egregiously, other versions that use the n-word. The appearance of another teepee on the outskirts of the closing illustration is perplexing�is it a plaything like the soccer goals? Or just a visual balance for the ice cream truck? Or something else?
If it is intended to be "multicultural" I would guess that Native children are included, too, but are they? I think... not. That said, why try to reinvent this particular rhyme?! If I get this book, Ill be back.


Read more »

Monday, June 26, 2017

Debbie have you seen JOURNEY INTO MOHAWK COUNTRY by Harmen Meyndertsz von den Bogaert and George OConnor

Debbie have you seen JOURNEY INTO MOHAWK COUNTRY by Harmen Meyndertsz von den Bogaert and George OConnor


Debbie, have you seen...
A reader writes to ask me if Ive read Journey Into Hawk Country. I havent. Heres the synopsis from WorldCat:
An illustrated childrens version of the journal of a young Dutch trader, Harmen Meyndertsz van den Bogaert, who journeyed into the land of the Iroquois Indians, a Mowhawk tribe that controlled the trade routes in the area, in 1634, seeking to bolster the Dutch trade in what is now New York State.

It came out in 2006 and theres quite a lot written about it. Heres one well-sourced essay, written by Melissa L. Melon: Our Minds in the Gutters: Sexuality and Reader Responsibility in George OConnors Graphic Novel, Journey into Mohawk Country.

If I get the book, Ill be back.

Read more »

Sunday, June 25, 2017

Debbie have you seen RED MOON RISING by K A Holt

Debbie have you seen RED MOON RISING by K A Holt


Woah. Some books are so.... out there, that I have a hard time wrapping my head around them. K. A. Holts Red Moon Rising is one of those books. Heres the synopsis:

Space-farmer Rae Darling is kidnapped and trained to become a warrior against her own people in this adventurous middle grade space western.
Rae Darling and her family are colonists on a moon so obscure it doesn�t merit a name. Life is hard, water is scarce, and the farm work she does is grueling. But Rae and her sister Temple are faced with an added complication�being girls is a serious liability in their strict society. Even worse, the Cheese�the colonists� name for the native people on the moon�sometimes kidnap girls from the human colony. And when Rae�s impetuous actions disrupt the fragile peace, the Cheese come for her and Temple.
Though Rae and Temple are captives in the Cheese society, they are shocked to discover a community full of kindness and acceptance. Where the human colonists subjugated women, the Cheese train the girls to become fierce warriors. Over time, Temple forgets her past and becomes one of the Cheese, but Rae continues to wonder where her loyalties truly lie. When her training is up, will she really be able to raid her former colony? Can she kidnap other girls, even if she might be recruiting them to a better life?
When a Cheese raid goes wrong and the humans retaliate, Rae�s loyalty is put to the ultimate test. Can Rae find a way to restore peace�and preserve both sides of herself?


Did you read the synopsis? Every word of it? Do you see what I mean?

The moon in this story has been colonized.

The native people who lived there are called "the Cheese."

They kidnap girls from "the human colony."

So... are the Cheese not human?

The Cheese kidnap the women to turn them into warriors who will fight against with the Cheese--against the humans.

Rae and her sister find out that the Cheese treat women better than the humans did.

IS THIS ALL SOUNDING FAMILIAR TO YOU?

I need one of those images of face palm, or head desk. Or a cool GIF. Daniel Jos� Older always tweets some excellent ones. Where does he find those, I wonder?!

Red Moon Rising is out this year, from...  Wait for it...  A major publisher! It is from Margaret K. McElderry, which is an imprint of Simon and Schuster. That is one of the Big Five! Big bucks for the author, big bucks for the promo of the book.

Im certainly being cynical in what Ive said. Maybe Ill regret it. Maybe this book is gonna rock.

Ill be back.

Update: Saturday Feb 27

Author Martha Brockenbrough submitted a comment, noting that my use of "big bucks" suggests that people can make a living with their writing. Im glad for her note. Being published by a big house does give writers a huge leg up in terms of visibility of their book, but it doesnt mean the writer can quit their day job(s). That could come later, after a lot of success and a lot of work, but it isnt the norm.
Read more »

Sunday, June 18, 2017

Debbie have you seen SOME KIND OF COURAGE by Dan Gemeinhart

Debbie have you seen SOME KIND OF COURAGE by Dan Gemeinhart


Jessica, a reader of AICL, wrote to ask me about Dan Gemeinharts Some Kind of Courage. Out in 2016 from Scholastic, heres the synopsis:

Joseph Johnson has lost just about everyone hes ever loved. He lost his pa in an accident. He lost his ma and his little sister to sickness. And now, hes lost his pony-fast, fierce, beautiful Sarah, taken away by a man who had no right to take her.
Joseph can sure enough get her back, though. The odds are stacked against him, but he isnt about to give up. He will face down deadly animals, dangerous men, and the fury of nature itself on his quest to be reunited with the only family he has left.
Because Joseph Johnson may have lost just about everything. But he hasnt lost hope. And he hasnt lost the fire in his belly that says hes getting his Sarah back-no matter what.
The critically acclaimed author of The Honest Truth returns with a poignant, hopeful, and action-packed story about hearts that wont be tamed... and spirits that refuse to be broken.


It is a middle grade Western, set in 1890. A couple of things I see via Google Books give me pause:
"Shes half Indian pony, so shes got some spirit, but she aint nothing but perfect with me."
"It was Indians. [...] The boys eyes narrowed. He bared his teeth like a wolf and snarled a word low and mean in his native tongue."
I will try to get a copy to read/review. If I do, Ill be back!
Read more »

Saturday, June 17, 2017

Debbie have you seen MacMillan Kirkers MULTICULTURAL STORYTIME MAGIC

Debbie have you seen MacMillan Kirkers MULTICULTURAL STORYTIME MAGIC


A reader wrote to ask me if Ive seen Kathy MacMillan and Christine Kirkers Multicultural Storytime Magic. Published in 2012 by ALA Editions, heres the description:
Storytime audiences grow ever more diverse, and it s important that the materials used in programs reflect that richness of experience. Multiculturalism need not be an occasional initiative attached to particular holidays. In this book best-selling authors MacMillan and Kirker offer a new paradigm for multicultural programs, one in which diversity is woven into any and every storytime, no matter what the topic. Arranged thematically around dozens of popular storytime themes, the authors
  • Present original and traditional resources from all over the world that will enrich storytimes for ages 2 through 5
  • Offer concrete book recommendations, fingerplays, and other activities that can be integrated into existing storytimes
  • Include download links for flannelboard and stick puppet patterns, and illustrations of American Sign Language signs
With numerous activities and programming suggestions, this book will seamlessly integrate and enhance cultural awareness for children all year round.

On ALA Editions website, theyve provided some of the worksheets for activities in the book. Heres a screen capture of the top half of one page for the "House for Me" guessing game:




Heres another:




This is not ok! I am guessing that the editor at ALA Editions who worked on MacMillan and Kirkers book, and MacMillan and Kirker, too, assumed that using an award winning book--Mary Ann Hobermans A House Is a House for Me--seemed a good choice, but it isnt.  It wasnt ok in 1978 when Hobermans book came out, and it sure as heck isnt ok for it to be in a resource book published by ALA Editions in 2012, either.

A House is A House for Me is set in the present day. It shows children in a tree house (which is generally considered something for children to play in), or a cardboard box (which is also considered something for children to play in), beneath a beach umbrella or a table, or in a snow house made on a snowy day. Theres a castle for a duchess and one for a king, too. All the other "houses" are for insects, animals, or other items ("a sandwich is a home for some ham").

As the worksheet suggests, theres one other category of houses:



If you havent been reading articles about the ways that Native Americans are depicted in childrens books, that page might seem fine to you. It isnt. For decades, people have written about the problems in using igloos and tipis to represent Native peoples. They are real things and are in use by some people today but Hobermans book moves the time frame to present day. Certainly some Plains Indians use their tipis today as a home, but most live in houses and use their tipis for gatherings. Not all Eskimos today or ever, lived in igloos. Their use is specific to a geographical location and, in many cases, purpose.

"A pueblos a house for a Hopi." That is a bit clunky. I have a traditional adobe home. It is not attached to others in the village like the one in Hobermans book, but some pueblo people live in those villages in some of the pueblos. That sentence could be improved if she wrote "A pueblos a house for Hopis." Plural. As is, it tells us that the entire village houses one Hopi.

The wigwam for a Mohee? Thats not ok. Who are the Mohee? I dont know. Do you? I can find "Mohee" in several sources about a folksong, My Little Mohee. I also find a bit of info about it in a book titled The Lasting of the Mohicans. But really: there is no tribal nation that I know of that is called the Mohee.

Another way to think about this page is the one put forth by Guy Jones and Sally Moomaw in Lessons From Turtle Island (which I highly recommend, by the way). They wrote:
Non-Native children often believe that all American Indian people live in tipis. There is a reason for this erroneous idea. Books, cartoons, and movies typically show all Native people living in the past, most often in the tipi, the traditional abode for the plains Nations. For example, What Can You Do With a Pocket? (Merriam 1964) shows generic Indians in front of tipis. Some teachers try to counter this by studying the historic abodes of various Native Nations. Few teachers or books, however, show the homes of Native peoples today. Books such as A House Is a House for Me (Hoberman 1978), still being sold in bookstores as of this writing, continue to lock Native peoples in houses of the past (p. 13):
An igloos a house for an Eskimo.
A tepees a house for a Cree.
A pueblos a house for a Hopi.
And a wigwam may hold a Mohee.
This stanza is clearly an attempt on the authors part to reflect the diversity of Native Nations, and perhaps to counter the prevalent image that all Native peoples traditional lived in tipis. However, the attempt is flawed because the author portrays Native peoples in the past and not in the present. A House Is a House for Me is a clear example of how a well-meant effort to diversity curriculum can go badly astray if all the factors are not considered.
A third way to think about that page is this: why is there only a page about Native homes? Wheres the pages about the kinds of houses that other peoples lived in? I hasten to add that Im not advocating for those pages, because theyll just do what the one on Native houses does: tell children that a particular group lives in a house that is unlike the ones that children see as the norm. In other words, adding those pages would make other groups exotic, too, and cast them into time frame that may not reflect the houses they live in today.

Last, most of the structures the kids are shown in are places of play, of imagination. It is a bit jarring to think of the Native homes in that framework.

I have no doubt that everyone involved in the making of A House Is a House for Me and Multicultural Storytime Magic had good intentions, but it gets tiring to talk about good intentions, again and again.

When "good intentions" is our default, were doing a disservice to the children who are on the receiving end of those good intentions, and we are likely contributing to the likelihood that well see other books that do the same thing. We saw that very thing, in fact, last year, in Home by Carson Ellis. See what Sam Bloom at Reading While White said about Home and see what I said, too.

We can do better, right?

Read more »

Monday, June 12, 2017

Debbie have you seen DREAMLAND BURNING by Jennifer Latham

Debbie have you seen DREAMLAND BURNING by Jennifer Latham


A reader has written to ask me if Ive seen Dreamland Burning, by Jennifer Latham. It is due out in February of 2017, from Little, Brown Books for Young Readers.

Heres the synopsis:

When seventeen-year-old Rowan Chase finds a skeleton on her familys property, she has no idea that investigating the brutal century-old murder will lead to a summer of painful discoveries about the past... and the present.
Nearly one hundred years earlier, a misguided violent encounter propels seventeen-year-old Will Tillman into a racial firestorm. In a country rife with violence against blacks and a hometown segregated by Jim Crow, Will must make hard choices on a painful journey towards self discovery and face his inner demons in order to do whats right the night Tulsa burns.
Through intricately interwoven alternating perspectives, Jennifer Latham�s lightning-paced page-turner brings the Tulsa race riot of 1921 to blazing life and raises important question about the complex state of US race relations � both yesterday and today.


From reviews at Goodreads, I gather that Will Tillman is half White and half Native, 17 years old, and lives in Tulsa, in 1921. If I get a copy and read it, Ill be back.


Read more »

Debbie have you seen S D Nelsons SITTING BULL LAKOTA WARRIOR AND DEFENDER OF HIS PEOPLE

Debbie have you seen S D Nelsons SITTING BULL LAKOTA WARRIOR AND DEFENDER OF HIS PEOPLE


Last year, I referenced S. D. Nelsons Sitting Bull: Lakota Warrior and Defender of His People in an article I did for School Library Journal. I hadnt read it then, and havent studied it yet, but have had some questions about it (hence, it is now in my "Debbie--have you seen" category). I do have a copy and want to say a few words about it. (Update: It was published in 2015 by Abrams.)

Im critical of books wherein the writer has invented dialogue for a real person. As a scholar in childrens literature who works very hard to help others see biased, stereotypical, inaccurate, romantic and derogatory depictions of Native peoples in childrens books, invented dialogue looms large for me.

In short: I need to know if there is evidence or documentation that the person actually said those words. This concern holds, whether the writer is Native or not.

In Nelsons Sitting Bull, the entire text is invented dialogue--and invented thoughts.

It is constructed as a first person biography. It is presented to us as if Sitting Bull is telling us his life story, after hes been killed. Along the way, we have some dialogue, but mostly we have what Nelson imagines Sitting Bull to have thought.

On February 1, 2016 in The Stories in Between, Julie Danielson wrote:
Increasingly, today�s readers also want to see dialogue attribution in the back matter of biographies. That�s because invented dialogue is still a touchy subject. You have those who think that it has no place and that any sort of made-up dialogue puts the biography squarely in the category of historical fiction. Then you have those who think such dialogue is acceptable, helps bring the story to life, and can still be considered nonfiction. In 2014, Betsy Bird wrote here about her changing feelings on the subject (�In general I stand by my anti-faux dialogue stance but recently I�ve been cajoled into softening, if not abandoning, my position�), which made me nod my head a lot.
Here�s where I (and many others) draw the line: if a biographer invents dialogue or shifts around facts in any sort of way, they need to come clean about this in the back matter. A great example of this is Greg Pizzoli�s Tricky Vic: The Impossibly True Story of the Man Who Sold the Eiffel Tower, the story of con artist Robert Miller, published last year and named a Kirkus Best Book of 2015. There�s a line in the starred review of the book that states: �The truth behind Miller�s exploits is often difficult to discern, and Pizzoli notes the research challenges in an afterword.� 
"Come clean" is, perhaps, a loaded way to characterize what Danielson is calling for, but I think it is an important call. I want to know what Nelson made up.

Clearly, this is not a hard and fast rule. If it was, Sitting Bull would not have been selected as an Honor Book by the American Indian Library Association.  And--this isnt the first time the field of childrens literature has looked critically at invented dialogue. Myra Zarnowskis chapter, Intermingling fact and Fiction, published in 2001 in The Best in Childrens Nonfiction, has a good overview.

If I do an in-depth look at Sitting Bull, Ill be back. For now, though, I am not comfortable recommending it, and I may revisit what I said about his Buffalo Bird Girl when I wrote about it, back in 2013. It, too, is a biography.

I anticipate questions from readers who wonder if S.D. Nelson ought to get a pass on invented dialogue because he is Lakota. My question is: did he work with any of Sitting Bulls descendants as he wrote the story? Did any of them read the manuscript? If they did, and they found it acceptable, Id love to see that in the book. On the cover, in fact! If I do hear anything like that, Ill be back to update this post.
Read more »

Saturday, June 10, 2017

Debbie have you seen Lane Smiths AUGIE HOBBLE

Debbie have you seen Lane Smiths AUGIE HOBBLE


A reader who saw my review of Lane Smiths There Is a Tribe of Kids wrote to ask if Ive read his Return to Augie Hobble. It got starred reviews from Booklist, and Publishers Weekly, and Kirkus... Published in 2015 by Roaring Book Press, heres the synopsis:
Augie Hobble lives in a fairy tale?or at least Fairy Tale Place, the down-on-its-luck amusement park managed by his father. Yet his life is turning into a nightmare: hes failed creative arts and has to take summer school, the girl he has a crush on wont acknowledge him, and Hogg Wills and the school bullies wont leave him alone. Worse, a succession of mysterious, possibly paranormal, events have him convinced that hes turning into a werewolf. At least Augie has his notebook and his best friend Britt to confide in?until the unthinkable happens and Augies life is turned upside down, and those mysterious, possibly paranormal, events take on a different meaning.

I was at the local library this afternoon and got a copy. As soon as I can, Ill be back with a review. It is getting bumped up on my list because it is set in New Mexico...
Read more »

Debbie have you seen Jean Craighead Georges THE TALKING EARTH

Debbie have you seen Jean Craighead Georges THE TALKING EARTH


A librarian wrote to ask me about Jean Craighead Georges The Talking Earth. Published in 1983 by HarperCollins, it is available in Spanish and Catalan. It is available as an audiobook, too. Most people who work in childrens literature know that Georges Julie of the Wolves won the Newbery Medal in 1972. Those of you who pay attention to depictions of Native people know that there is a lot wrong with Julie of the Wolves. 

Ill get a copy of The Talking Earth at the library. From what I see online, I anticipate there will be many problems with it, too. Elders who cross their arms when they speak to kids? Elders who sit cross legged on the ground? Not ok.

In the opening pages, the main character sees her grandfathers medicine bundle. I doubt that a Seminole writer would have that whole section in there. There are some things that are not shared with the public...

And the names! The main character is Billy Wind. Her sister is Mary Wind. Her father is Iron Wind. Her mother is Whispering Wind. Her grandfather is Charlie Wind.

Theres some parts that display an outsiders writing, like when Billy and Mary walk to the dugout (p. 10):
It was tied beside the airboat, a flat boat with a motorized fan that "blew" passengers across the saw grass in the watery prairie the Indians called the pa-hay-okee.
Those are supposed to be Billys thoughts but that sounds more like George herself, an outsider. Honestly, I dont want to read this book.
Read more »

Friday, June 2, 2017

Debbie have you seen John Flanagans THE GHOSTFACES

Debbie have you seen John Flanagans THE GHOSTFACES


A reader wrote to ask me if Ive seen John Flanagans The Ghostfaces. I havent, so am adding it to the "Debbie--have you seen" series.

Heres the synopsis:
From John Flanagan, author of the worldwide bestselling Rangers Apprentice, comes a brand-new chapter in the adventures of young Skandians who form a different kind of family--a brotherband.
When the Brotherband crew are caught in a massive storm at sea, they�re blown far off course and wash up on the shores of a land so far west that Hal can�t recognize it from any of his maps. Eerily, the locals are nowhere in sight, yet the Herons have a creeping feeling they are being watched.
Suddenly the silence is broken when a massive, marauding bear appears, advancing on two children. The crew springs into action and rescues the children from the bear�s clutches, which earns them the gratitude and friendship of the local Mawagansett tribe, who finally reveal themselves. But the peace is short-lived. The Ghostfaces, a ruthless, warlike tribe who shave their heads and paint their faces white, are on the warpath once more. It�s been ten years since they raided the Mawagansett village, but they�re coming back to pillage and reap destruction. As the enemy approaches, the Herons gear up to help their new friends repel an invasion.

"Ruthless, warlike tribe"?!

"On the warpath"?!

My head hurts just reading the synopsis.  One red flag after another! It came out on June 14, 2016 from Penguin.

According to Amazon, it is already #1 in its Kindle Store and in the Childrens Books category, too, in the "Fairy Tales, Folk Tales & Myths/Norse."

If I can get Flanagans The Ghostfaces, Ill be back with a review.

Read more »

Debbie have you seen Joseph Bruchacs THE LONG RUN

Debbie have you seen Joseph Bruchacs THE LONG RUN


Out this year from 7th Generation is Joseph Bruchacs The Long Run. It is in their PathFinders series.
Follow Travis Hawk on a cross-country trek as he escapes a world of brutality and uncertainty and puts his trust, and even his very life, in the hands of total strangers. Traviss story is one of struggle, survival, risk and resilience, navigating a solo journey of hundreds of miles to seek a safe haven far from the demons of his past.
Ill be back with a review!
Read more »

Wednesday, May 31, 2017

Debbie have you seen TRU NELLE by G Neri

Debbie have you seen TRU NELLE by G Neri


A reader asked me about G. Neris Tru & Nelle. Heres the synopsis:
Long before they became famous writers, Truman Capote (In Cold Blood) and Harper Lee (To Kill a Mockingbird) were childhood friends in Monroeville, Alabama. This fictionalized account of their time together opens at the beginning of the Great Depression, when Tru is seven and Nelle is six. They love playing pirates, but they like playing Sherlock and Watson-style detectives even more. It�s their pursuit of a case of drugstore theft that lands the daring duo in real trouble. Humor and heartache intermingle in this lively look at two budding writers in the 1930s South.
With Harper Lees death and the publication last year of Go Set A Watchman, this book is timely and could do quite well. My quick look inside in the "look inside" feature at Amazon tells me theres a character in it named Indian Joe.

If I get it, and read it, Ill be back. If you got it, and read it, let me know!
Read more »